Hello dear
Welcome To Papa Luigi's
Papa Luigi's is a beloved gem located in Cudahy, WI, renowned for its inviting atmosphere and exceptional Italian cuisine. Patrons rave about the variety of flavors, from the delectable Garlic Bread with Papa’s signature marinara to the indulgent Crab Linguini, each dish crafted with fresh ingredients. The restaurant fosters a welcoming environment, reminiscent of cherished neighborhood eateries, making every visit feel like dining at home. With attentive staff and a clean setting, it’s no wonder guests return frequently for the Chicken Parmesan and famous thin-crust pizza. Make sure to try the lasagna—it’s a standout!
Taste the best
Discover Our Menu
Garlic Bread
US$7.80Breaded Chicken Filet Sandwich
US$18.75Crab Linguini
US$34.35
Sal's Seafood Sensation
US$35.89Shrimp Skewers
US$30.45Crab Fusilli
US$34.35Beer Battered Cod
US$23.40Broasted Chicken Dinner
US$23.40Shrimp Basket
US$24.99 About
Papa Luigi's
Welcome to Papa Luigi's, a charming eatery nestled in the heart of Cudahy, Wisconsin. Located at 3475 E Layton Ave, this restaurant stands as a beacon for those craving authentic Italian comfort food. With a reputation for excellence, Papa Luigi's offers a delightful atmosphere where culinary magic happens, promising warmth, flavor, and a taste of Italy without the need for a passport.
The moment you step inside, you're greeted with an inviting ambiance that feels like a cherished neighborhood gathering spot. Customers rave about their experiences, with consistent mentions of friendly staff and a welcoming vibe. From the aroma of freshly baked Garlic Bread served with the restaurant's signature Marinara Sauce to the rich flavors found in their renowned Lasagna, dining at Papa Luigi's is nothing short of a delectable journey.
Start your meal with a satisfying appetizer—whether it’s the heavenly Cheesy Garlic Bread or the buttery indulgence of Mama Maria's Buttery Garlic Bread, your taste buds are in for a treat. For entrées, don’t miss the astonishing Beer Battered Cod or the succulent Broasted Chicken Dinner, both of which keep customers coming back for more. The Chicken Parmesan is a must-try, frequently cited as a top favorite by regulars.
Every bite at Papa Luigi's tells a story, infused with the rich heritage of Italian cuisine. Diners appreciate the freshly prepared salads and the quality ingredients that create mouthwatering dishes. The camaraderie of the staff enhances the experience, with bartenders like Alicia noted for their personable and attentive service, making guests feel right at home. As one patron mentioned, "It feels like home," and that sentiment resonates throughout this establishment.
Whether you’re dining in with family, catching up with friends at the bar, or enjoying a quiet meal for one while watching a game, Papa Luigi's caters to all with grace. As you plan your visit, remember that the journey to this delightful spot is certainly worth the drive. Discover why it's a local favorite – indulge in the flavors of Italy with every dish, and create lasting memories at Papa Luigi's.
With each visit, you’ll discover a little more about what makes this restaurant special. We, at Foodjoyy, encourage you to experience the charm and culinary delights of Papa Luigi’s for yourself.
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Great atmosphere. On a Saturday night our party of 4 without a reservation was given a 20 min wait estimate. We sat at the bar yo grab a drink and wait. Our table was ready before we were two swallows in. As a rewards member my uncle got a free appetizer. The eggplant was amazing! And then for sure get the lasagna! DELICIOUS!!!! ”
“ The food was absolutely delicious. There were 4 of us; each had a different entree and we were all happy. The atmosphere reminded us of an old neighborhood restaurant serving 5 food. ”
“ We visit here frequently. The food is very delicious with all the food flavors you are looking for. The salads are fresh, the Chicken Parmesan is top 3 of my favorites. Also from the host/hostess,the wait staff, and even the bus boys are very good at their job. The bathrooms are super clean. And last but not least the Bar Tenders make Some fantastic drinks, and very personable, feels like home. Thanks guys for the service on March 26. See you soon. ”
“ Excellent food, friendly waitress named Ellie, clean and nice mellow atmosphere...I will come here every week from now on! ”
“ We dined at the bar and watched the football games. Thank you, Teddy for an amazing afternoon! Alicia was the best bartender... she is a keeper! Very attentive and a lot of fun! Pizza was delicious... perfect thin crust, flavorful sauce and quality ingredients. Garlic bread is to die for! A bit of a distance to drive to Papa Luigi's, but definitely worth the trip... I look forward to returning and trying some of the other dishes that are offered! ”
“ Never a disappointment when dining in or ordering take out from Papa Luigis! The food is awesome! I highly recommend Sals Jumbo wings! And the pizza is always on point! ”
“ I absolutely love this place. I get delivery most if time. My food is always fresh. Hot and delicious. When I call, the person no matter who it is they are always polite and courteous. If a mess up happens, they immediately rectify it. I can't say enough good things about this establishment. Only place I order from in Cudahy. They have anything you could want. It's all top notch in my opinion. Ty to the owners, chefs, and everyone else that works there. Melody Burmeister ”
“ This is hands down the best pizza I have ever had. It was so hot and crispy, the distribution of toppings, cheese, and sauce was absolute perfection! The garlic bread was incredible as well, the love in this food is real. It’s so hard to find good food these days and you guys really deserve a round of applause, because you could really charge double the amount of money and I’d still be paying it! Just wanted to also add that the service was fantastic, it was kept so hot and fresh as if I was in the restaurant, thank you! ”